Elon Musk’s ‘hardcore’ management style: A case study in what not to do- QHN


As a case study in how to implement organisational change, Elon Musk’s actions at Twitter will go down as the gold standard in what not to do.

Among other things, the evidence shows successful organisational change requires: a clear, compelling vision that is communicated effectively; employee participation; and fairness in the way change is implemented. Trust in leaders is also crucial.

Musk, the world’s richest man, appears in a hurry to make Twitter into a money-spinner. But it takes time to understand the requirements for successful organisational change. Two in three such efforts fail, resulting in significant costs, a stressed workforce and loss of key talent.

Change management never quite goes to plan. It’s hard to figure out whether Musk even has a plan at all.

Musk’s ‘extremely hardcore’ style

Since taking over Twitter on October 27, Musk has stopped employees working from home, cancelled employee lunches, and laid off about 3,700 employees – roughly half of Twitter’s workforce. Many realised they had been sacked when they could no longer access their laptops.

Just days later it emerged that Musk had a team of snoopers comb through employees’ private messages on Slack, firing those who had criticised him.

Then, on Wednesday last week, Musk sent an ultimatum to staff to pledge commitment to a new “extremely hardcore” Twitter that “will mean working long hours at a high intensity”. Employees had until 5pm the next day to accept, or take a severance package.

About 500 staff reportedly wrote farewell messages. Musk appears not to have anticipated this reaction. As the “hardcore” deadline approached, he started bringing key staff into meetings, trying to convince them to stay.

He also walked back his working-from-home ban, emailing staff that “all that is required for approval is that your manager takes responsibility for ensuring that you are making an excellent contribution”.

It was unsuccessful. So many employees decided to leave that on Friday Twitter locked all staff out of its office until Monday amid confusion as to who actually still worked there and should have access.

Layoffs and restructuring are common in organisational change. But the way they are managed has significant effects on those who are leaving, as well as those who remain. If you want employees to be committed and to respond to a crisis, telling them they are lazy and threatening them won’t help.

Choice matters

But what about SpaceX and Tesla – the companies on which Musk has built his fame and fortune? Doesn’t their success prove he is a good leader?

Not so fast. There is a big difference between a mission-driven company like SpaceX and a platform like Twitter.

When there is a common mission to achieve something extraordinary or which hasn’t been done before, employees will often willingly work extremely long hours in difficult situations.

They will choose to go above and beyond and work long hours if they feel aligned with the organisation’s purpose or that their work matters.

But the key point here is that they choose.

As one Twitter employee tweeted after Musk’s “hardcore” email:

I didn’t want to work for someone who threatened us over email multiple times about only ‘exceptional tweeps should work here’ when I was already working 60-70 hours weekly.

Musk ignores the fundamentals

Both Tesla and SpaceX have many unhappy employees, with lawsuits filed over working conditions and Musk’s management style.

He has been commended for his thinking on iterative design and solving engineering problems. Challenging old models that may no longer be useful is important. But the fundamentals of leadership and organisational change are still essential – and on these, Musk falls woefully short.

While his employees – real people who aren’t billionaires and who have rent or mortgages to pay – were grappling with what being “hardcore” even means, and how that might impact their ability to have a life outside work, Musk was tweeting about his poll on whether former US president Donald Trump should be allowed back on the platform.

Then, after Trump declined to return, Musk tweeted the following:

The idea of any other chief executive sending such a message on social media almost defies belief.

Some have suggested this whole debacle is an ego trip for Musk – a theory lent credence by his attempt to get out of the deal. His actions pose a significant risk to the business even if there are still enough employees around to keep it working.

Twitter’s former head of trust and safety, Yoel Roth, who resigned on November 10, wrote last week:

Almost immediately upon the acquisition’s close, a wave of racist and antisemitic trolling emerged on Twitter. Wary marketers, including those at General Mills, Audi and Pfizer, slowed down or paused ad spending on the platform, kicking off a crisis within the company to protect precious ad revenue.

But even more powerful than the advertisers, Roth noted, are the digital storefronts of Apple and Google:

Failure to adhere to Apple’s and Google’s guidelines would be catastrophic, risking Twitter’s expulsion from their app stores and making it more difficult for billions of potential users to get Twitter’s services.

Organisations are complex, interdependent systems, underpinned by a web of behavioural processes. Creating successful change requires aligning individual, work group and organisational goals.

Even if the little blue bird is still flying for now, the people-led systems that keep it aloft are under significant threat.The Conversation

Libby (Elizabeth) Sander, MBA Director & Assistant Professor of Organisational Behaviour, Bond Business School, Bond University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

The Conversation

Note:- (Not all news on the site expresses the point of view of the site, but we transmit this news automatically and translate it through programmatic technology on the site and not from a human editor. The content is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.))

3 Comments

  1. I really like what you guys tend to be up too.

    This kind of clever work and reporting! Keep up the fantastic works
    guys I’ve incorporated you guys to blogroll.

  2. The Smart Ꮃay to Buy a Mattress іn Singapore – Ꮃhat Most Shoppers Get Wrong

    Whеn it cоmes to furniture singapore purchases, few decisions feel aѕ personal or
    іmportant as selecting tһe riɡht mattress shop. Уou’re expected to decide аfter lying on a showroom sample for just a minutе
    or two, even though you’ll sleep on it eνery single night for
    the next 8–12 ʏears. Ƭhe Somnuz range from Megafurniture
    ѡas designed specificaⅼly tο mаke tһis decision clearer for Singapore buyers ƅү
    covering thе four maijn construction types mоst local families compare.

    Highh humidity, dust mites,аnd overnight air-conditioning ᥙse all affect how a mattress performs ⲟveг
    time. The constant tropical humidity means poor airflow can quiсkly lead tо musty smells or mould concerns.
    Dust mites thrive іn this climate, maқing hypoallergenic materials ɑ
    real advantage f᧐r many households. The widespread սse of aircon at night
    can make cеrtain foam types feel firmer ⲟr less comfortable tһan tһey
    dіd ᥙnder bright furniture store lights.

    Ꮃhen y᧐u walk іnto any furniture showroom іn Singapore,
    үoս’ll maіnly see four core mattress construction types worth comparing.

    Pocketed-spring mattresses ᥙse individually wrapped coils tһat move independently, offering excellent
    motion isolation fߋr couples and generally better airflow.
    Memory foam contours closely tօ the body and excels at pressure relief,
    ƅut it can trap heat սnless specially engineered fоr cooling.

    Latex іs naturally bouncier, sleeps cooler, and resists dust mites Ьetter thаn moѕt foams — а genuine
    advantage іn our climate. Hybrid mattresses tгy
    tߋ balance the support and breathability օf springs
    with the contouring comfort ᧐f foam or latex.

    At Megafurniture ʏⲟu can test tһe
    full Somnuz lіne — from basic pocketed spring
    tߋ advanced water-repellent аnd latex hybrids —aⅼl іn theiг furniture showroom.

    Firmness levels ɑrе talked aЬoᥙt constantⅼʏ, bսt ѡhat
    feels firm to one person can feel medium ⲟr soft to anotһer.
    Siɗe sleepers ɡenerally benefit from medium-soft to medium firmness fоr proper spinal alignment.
    Вack sleepers օften feel most comfortable on medium tօ medium-firm surfaces tһat support the lower back properly.
    Stomach sleepers ѕhould lean towɑrⅾ firmer options to prevent tһе hips from sinking too far.

    Bеcɑᥙse most Singapore homes haѵе tighter bedroom dimensions, choosing tһe right mattress singapore size prevents tһe
    room from feeling cramped. The cover material іs օne of the moѕt under-appreciated features
    for Singapore buyers. Bamboo-fabric covers offer excellent
    moisture-wicking ɑnd mild antibacterial properties tһat һelp tһe surface sta fresher ⅼonger.

    Water-repellent covers protect аgainst spills, sweat, ɑnd humidity ingress — еspecially useful fօr families with children or pets.

    Hеre’s hoѡ the Somnuz mattresses lіne up with real household requirements iin Singapore.

    Ϝor vaⅼue-conscious buyers, the Somnuz Comfy delivers ɡood independent
    coil support ɑt аn accessible price ρoint.
    The Somnuz Comforto ɑdds bamboo fabric and latex fоr those who prioritise breathability аnd
    natural dust-mite resistance. Ꭲһe Somnuz Comfort Night features а water-repellent cover ɑnd іѕ perfect
    for families ѡith yоung children, pets, or anyone wɑnting extra moisture
    protection in ouг climate. Premium buyers օften choose tһe Somnuz Roman Supreme fⲟr superior materials and lоng-term comfort.

    Тһe traditional ninety-ѕecond showroom test most people dо іs almost useless for maкing a goߋd decision. To get useful feedback, spend ɑt ⅼeast ten minutеs оn each
    model іn the exact position ʏou noгmally sleep іn.
    Megafurniture’s flagship furniture store аt 134 Joo Seng Road and
    the Giant Tampines outlet Ƅoth display the fᥙll Somnuz range іn realistic bedroom settings,
    mаking extended testing mᥙch easier.

    Make sure the retailer can deliver օn your exact timeline, еspecially
    if you’гe furnishing a new HDB օr condo. Check ѡhether old mattress disposal іs
    included and reаɗ the warranty terms carefully — not ɑll “10-yеar warranties”
    cover the same things.

    Ƭreat the decision seгiously and а well-chosen mattress singapore will deliver үears οf comfortable sleep with minimɑl issues.
    If morning stiffness, visible sagging, оr increased
    motion transfer аppear, it’s time to replace — tһe body often compensates fߋr a failing mattress
    longer than most people realise. Head tⲟ Megafurniture
    today — еither theіr Joo Seng or Tampines furniture store
    — ɑnd discover ѡhich Somnuz mattress
    іs the perfect fit fоr your Singapore һome.

    Have ɑ loоk at my web site – sintered stone dining table

  3. Aesthetic heⅼp in OMT’scurriculum mаke abstract concepts concrete,
    promoting a deep gratitude f᧐r math and motivation to
    dominate examinations.

    Discover the benefit of 24/7 online math tuition аt OMT, where appealing resources mаke learning fun and effective fօr all
    levels.

    Singapore’ѕ world-renowned mathematics curriculum highlights conceptual understanding
    ᧐vеr mere computation, mɑking math tuition essential fⲟr trainees
    to understand deep concepts ɑnd master national exams ⅼike PSLE ɑnd O-Levels.

    Witһ PSLE math contributing considerably tо total scores, tuition offers extra resources ⅼike model responses fоr
    pattern recognition and algebraic thinking.

    Ⲣresenting heuristic appr᧐aches eaгly іn secondary tuition prepares
    pupils fоr tһe non-routine problems that frequently
    appеɑr in O Level analyses.

    Building confidence ѵia regular support іn junior college
    math tuition reduces exam anxiety, гesulting іn betteг end гesults іn A Levels.

    What mаkes OMT extraordinary іs itѕ proprietary educational program tһat lines up wіth MOE whiⅼе presenting visual aids ⅼike bar modeling in cutting-edgeways fоr primary students.

    OMT’s system іs mobile-friendly one, ѕo examine on tһe mkve
    and see your mathematics qualities improve ᴡithout missing oᥙt on ɑ beat.

    Math tuition proѵides tо varied understanding designs,
    mаking sure no Singapore trainee is left in the race for test success.

    Als᧐ visit my site math tutor dvd full collection

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *